EARL WATT
• Leader & Times
Seward County cannot require any form of payment in order to provide a Conditional Use Permit, according to representatives from Invenergy at Monday’s Seward County Commission meeting where the permit was approved by a 4-1 vote.
Even though they cannot require a payment, Thresher offered a “donation” as part of the agreement, but that gift came with strings attached. Should the State of Kansas make any changes to subsidies or institute any new fees, those costs would come straight off the “donation” to Seward County.
Local resident Carolyn Huddleston urged the commission to revisit that clause.
“I’d like to ask you also to return to this agreement and make some revisions,” Huddleston said. “Many points seem problematic, but two of them stand out to me. First is the clause that says any money Thresher has to pay in other taxes is going to come off what we get.”
Huddleston explained that a bill was proposed last year in the Kansas Senate that would establish taxes on wind turbines, something none of them currently pay.
“This would tax wind farms both on the basis of their name plate capacity and actual production,” Huddleston said. “The first tax would amount to $396,000 if there were 22 wind turbines and each is 4.5 megawatts. The second tax is more difficult to quantify, but based on the typical production of wind turbines in western kansas, it’s likely to be somewhere between $360,000 and $430,000. If both those taxes were instituted, we wouldn’t be getting one cent, and if only one was passed right there, we’d be losing about $400,000.”
Huddleston provided commissioners with information on how Oklahoma and Texas tax wind farms. Data also showed Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, West Virginia, Iowa and others have recently established similar wind taxes, and according to Huddleston, Kansas won’t be far behind.
“I think one or the other or both of those two taxes that have been proposed are likely coming within the next three years,” she said. “They would be in place by the time Thresher should start paying. And the agreement doesn’t say that tax paid in one calendar year can be taken off what is owed Seward County for that year. It just says tax paid. So is it that these taxes paid in 2027, 2028, and 2029 can be taken off what is owed us in 2030 and thereafter? Really, I urge you to go back to that statement and clarify it and also put in some minimum amount Thresher would have to pay us in lieu of taxes so that no matter what those other taxes might be, we will still be getting something.”
When commissioners were able to ask questions of Thresher/Invenergy, Commissioner Stanton asked about the “donation.”
“What does that do with the offset language in the CUP?” Stanton asked. “It would seem to indicate any taxes paid by you that were paid to Topeka, the contribution payment no longer comes to Seward County.”
Senior Vice President for Invenergy Meredith Abdou said her company worked to try to defeat that bill and will continue to try to defeat any state tax proposals.
“So Senate Bill 534 did come up last session,” Abdou said. “One of the biggest things we did is we reached out to all of our operating projects. We partner very much with the landowners and with the local communities, because the issue with the proposed version from Sen. (Caryn) Tyson was that the money from these projects would go to the state and not to the local communities, and we see that is a big flaw.”
Abdou said her company monitors legislative efforts to establish wind taxes and would continue to work against any proposals that would tax wind at the state level.
“We are engaged very actively across that, and we will make sure that continues to happen and make sure that those voices are heard, because I think one of the things that you all understand is if your community is the one hosting this project, all of the funds and all of the benefits should stay local,” Abdou said.
But if taxes are passed, Abdou conceded that Seward’s contribution would be lowered or removed, depending on the amount of taxes imposed by Kansas.
“From a perspective of how the actual document is written, you are correct, that if the state elected to say all of the property tax - you know, the contributions, property taxes, and, and they decided to change, fundamentally change how these projects, renewable or otherwise, are taxed, then what would happen and, and if those funds went to the state, it would be a reduction.”
Invenergy representative Alan Anderson also replied to Stanton’s question, stating the company needs certainty in its financial projections, and taxes needed to be predictable, even if that meant taking them from Seward County to pay Kansas.
“We’ve heard from many business owners tonight,” Anderson said. “The major thing for us is we have to have dependable financials. When we go out to build these projects, we have to engage banks, we have to engage financial institutions to get the funds for a construction loan to build it because these are high dollar, high capital projects. They have to know that there is a dependable amount we are going to pay over the life of the project to actually finance it and prove that it is, it is viable.”
Stanton than clarified his concern.
“We’re going to have a new legislature next year,” Stanton said. “Things are going to be very different. They were very clever in how they structured this bill, because it’s going to send money to the big school districts where the majority of votes sit, and those of us out here kind of know how that goes for us on a regular basis. I don’t know that you’re going to be successful, so what are you willing to do with this agreement to make sure that any funds pledged to us stay here regardless?”
Invenergy representatives continued to make the case that they would work with landowners and commissions where they have projects to press the Legislature not to enact taxes.
“We had commissioners across the state, we had landowners across the state making calls, and we think that they were extremely effective in that,” Anderson said. “We have engaged recently with legislators in Southwest Kansas, and none of them have raised to us if they are in support of any type of Senate Bill 534 in that fashion, form and fashion where it would increase the burden to renewables.”
Stanton continued to ask about the “donation” and whether or not Invenergy was willing to make sure Seward County would receive some level of “donation.”
“Are you willing to modify the way this is structured in the agreement?” he asked.
“I think it’s, it’s one of the major things for us, is that we have to have those dependable structures,” Anderson said. “For any business, a double taxation — so it, it is, is it — is it a true possibility that Seward County ends up with nothing? I do not believe that is the case.”
Stanton continued his questioning.
“But it is a possibility, correct?” Stanton asked. “I believe if the bill passes, Seward County gets nothing.”
Abdou continued to defend Invenergy’s approach and how it is difficult to predict legislative outcomes.
“It depends on what form and shape it passes,” Abdou said.
She then handed off to Anderson who said it is difficult to predict what the Legislature may or may not do.
“I’ve been working with (the Legislature) for 20 years, and we don’t know what’s going to come,” Anderson said. “Sena. Tyson sought the same thing last year. Who knows? But let me take a step back and remind what we’re talking about here. We’re talking about, as Meredith stated, a tax exemption that was set by the state that puts wind energy and generation on the same par as natural gas and anything else. If you go through the regime of property tax exemptions, you have a massive amount of entities and companies that have a greater tax exemption in the state ...”
But Stanton tried to redirect the conversation back to the proposed permit.
“I’m sorry to interrupt you, but this isn’t addressing my question,” Stanton said.
“Well, I’m going address your question because it’s actually completely illegal to hold up a permit based on a voluntary donation,” Anderson said. “So I just want to set the table if the chair would allow me. So if what we have is National Beef, commercial industrial manufacturing equipment is lifetime exempt, farm machinery and ranch equipment machinery, lifetime exempt. What we’ve done, which is different than any of the other entities that currently have those same exemptions, we’re offering a voluntary donation, and it’s critical that it’s understood it’s a voluntary donation, probably, I’m guessing, the only one that’s been done in the county. Based on that, then, we absolutely want to do, and that’s why we fought so hard to make sure the local communities are done, but we do have to have financial certainty, but remember that time period we’re talking about is a voluntary donation.”
But Anderson reiterated requiring any payment to the county was simply a courtesy of Invenergy rather than a requirement or condition of approving the permit.
“It is absolutely and clearly illegal within the state of Kansas to ask for what we call an exaction or a taxation on some parties that you pick and choose. That is why we’re real cautious about talking about it.”
Even though the “donation” was based on maximum numbers and the assumption the State of Kansas will not follow suit with Nebraksa and several other states that have implemented taxes and fees on wind generation, Anderson said the offer to make a contribution was genuine and can hopefully be paid.
“We’re going to do everything we can for the community, but we have to understand that different than any other entity that has this exemption,” Anderson said. “We want to give this voluntary payment to the county, and again, we’re going fight like heck to make sure it sticks.”
But whether the “donation” goes to Seward County or ends up being paid to the State of Kansas, Anderson said Invenergy needs protected against paying both.
“We’re absolutely saying, we’d like to give this, but we have to have certainty.”
Even after learning the county’s “donation” was not guaranteed, the commission voted 4-1 to approve the Conditional Use Permit.

