EARL WATT

    • Leader & Times

 

Several citizens spoke in favor and against the wind farm project at Monday’s Seward County Commission meeting prior to the 4-1 vote to approve the project. Commissioner Todd Stanton was the only vote against the project while Commissioners Jairo Vazquez, John Mettlen, Steve Helm and Clay Louderback all voted in favor of approving the Conditional use Permit for Thresher/Invenergy.

While Kathy Fitzgerald said she opposed wind, the also thought there was a clause that needed clarification. But before she discusses that, she opposed a public vote.

“I wanted to speak to you about the public advisory vote, which you've already made a decision on,” Fitzgerald said. “I was going to say that I appreciate the direction that you went with that. I'm opposed to the large scale wind farms for many of the reasons that have been stated previously, so I’m not going to go over those issues once again, but I just felt like this is too complicated and a complex issue to put on a public ballot, especially for people maybe who live in town that don't realize the impacts it has to those of us who live in our rural Seward County. So I agree with what you did tonight.”

Earlier, Stanton had made a motion to provide a public advisory vote, but the motion died form lack of a second.

Fitzgerald then suggested a review of the language of the agreement about whether or not the entire project had to be completed before payouts would be received.

“I would also challenge you as commissioners to make sure that the CUP truly protects Seward County,” Fitzgerald said. “There was one statement read by your attorney, a question that I would have that I would like for you to check into. They talk about if they don't build the full potential, will they still pay? Is that going to be a scapegoat that maybe is in there? So that's one thing that I would like for you to look at.”

Despite her concerns, the commission ultimately voted for the agreement without any changes or a review of the concerns raised by Fitzgerald.

“I am against large scale wind farms and I just appreciate all of the time that it's taken you guys working on this issue,” Fitzgerald said.

USD 483 Superintendent Dan Frisbee spoke in favor of the project. The district had already singed an agreement with Thresher/Invenergy, but he wanted to show support for Seward County doing the same.

“As a superintendent, I am here to advocate for my district,” Frisbee said. “My hope is that you would approve the Thresher wind project. This project will not only help my district, but others as well. My district, like others, is experiencing drastic declining enrollment and has aging buildings. In 2011, USD 483 had 736 students enrolled. As of today, we have 512 students enrolled. This is a loss of 224 students. Using the current base state aid per pupil, this is a loss of $1,257,760. Therefore, many items are not being fully funded, which forces districts to have to make up the difference. Last year, my district alone had to take over a million dollars out of our budget to be able to fully fund special education, and we did that. Our capital outlay fund is maxed out each year at eight mills, which roughly generates $890,000 per year, depending upon assessed valuations of the counties. This project would be able to provide student scholarships, support teacher retention, improve technology in the district, update aging buildings, and improve facilities such as our track, which has not been resurfaced since 2012. We need to improve our baseball facility. We need to improve other buildings. We need to provide a larger cafeteria for kismet elementary school where all of the students meet or eat and barely fit.”

According to Frisbee, he has seen several changes during his tenure with USD 483.

“I have been at USD 483 for 20 years, and I am proud of that,” he said. “And I can't tell you how many times our board has had the conversation of updating our confetti cake tile in the high school multiple times, but we didn't have the funds. The majority of these items can’t be completed without taxpayer dollars. I am asking for your support for the Thresher wind project on behalf of my students, my staff, and my teachers.”

Ryan Martin also addressed the commission and shared he had already provided information to the commissioners including that of a farming family in Hansford County, Texas who said wind was detrimental to their operation.

“I trust that you got my letter I sent you this last week, and in there, I'd also forwarded on the letter that had been written to me by the residents in Hansford County explaining what they have went through in this. And I also had shared with you videos and, this letter and videos were also in the Leader & Times,” Martin said. “I visited with the wife. She explained to me everything they'd gone through in this development had, how it crushed their dreams of enjoying life on their century-old farmstead. As she left my office holding back tears, she encouraged me to contact her husband. I did just that. I contacted him that afternoon and I explained what we were going through and he explained some of what they went through and I mentioned to him how this issue is being turned into a property rights debate. And his response was something I soon won't forget. It soon got quiet and then his volume cranked up about 50 decibels — about what we're allowing on the windmills. He said, ‘Property rights. Who though of my property rights? Where were my property rights? No one asked me how close I wanted them to my farm. No one asked me what it was going to do to the value of my home. Now I have an empty farmstead with very little value.’ Gentlemen, I've said it 100 times because I've been coming to this for about 15 months now, best I can guess — One person's property rights should never interfere with another person's ability to sell their property, maintain its value or enjoy living on it. When one person's property rights come at the expense of another person's property rights, that's not protecting property rights, that's infringing upon them. All of this land around here has been designated agricultural, not commercial or industrial. That's precisely why we have a conditional use permit. This allows the county to establish regulations for commercial and industrial developments while protecting the agricultural character of our county.”

Martin went on to explain his concerns about the CUP including possible legislation at the state level that would cause taxes to be imposed on wind turbines which would be taken from contributions to Seward County.

“Quite frankly, this cup appears to be written for the, benefit of Invenergy rather than for the protection of Seward County residents. The company obviously was aware of Senate Bill 534, whether everyone involved in this drafting, considering this CUP fully understood its impacts is another question. As I understand it, Seward County stands to receive no direct benefit from the property tax revenue with these turbines because of this provision in the senate, with the senate bill. The citizens deserve a clear explanation of exactly what financial benefits, if any, this county will receive.”

Martin also criticized the process which took place in executive sessions. A complaint has been filed with the Kansas Attorney General.

“It's become increasingly difficult to understand this process that seems to go so contrary to the concerns and wishes expressed by so many Seward County residents, whether it's the resistance to allowing a public vote or the continued efforts to move this development forward,” Martin said. “It increasingly appears that the county is negotiating on the behalf of Invenergy rather than negotiating for the best interest of its citizens. And I believe this conditional permit reinforces that perception.”

Martin then wanted clarification if any commissioner or administrator was receiving any benefits.

“I have a question for the seven individuals sitting in this room, five county commissioners, one administrator, and a planning and zoning administrator,” Martin said. “|Who's benefiting from this arrangement? Is anyone in this room receiving any sort of kickback? I mean, it's starting to look that way. Let me be clear, I'm asking a question. I'm not accusing of anyone of receiving a kickback, but citizens have every right to ask the question when public trust is being challenged. You have continued to move this wind development forward. You have opposed a public to vote on it. You have a conditional use permit that appears over- overwhelmingly in Invenergy's best interest. Let's not forget the planning and zoning meeting where citizens were limited to three minutes to speak while Invenergy had unlimited time at the beginning and the end for a rebuttal. How is this supposed to give citizens confidence that this process has been fair and balanced? Gentlemen, public trust is earned through transparency, fairness, and accountability. I'm asking each one of you to explain why the citizens of Seward County should believe this decision is being made in the best interest of this county rather than the best interest of Invenergy.  Gentlemen, this front row, you're not obligated to represent them. You're obligated to represent the citizens of this county. You even went as far as to reserve the whole front row for them.”