L&T Publisher Earl Watt

 

EDITOR’S NOTE — This was presented to the Seward County Commission Monday.

 

As the Seward County Commission, your two main responsibilities are to establish the county budget and set policy.

Both of these are to be done in public.

The Kansas Open Meetings Act KSA 75-4319, allows for some very narrow reasons to be able to meet privately, in executive session.

One of those reasons is called attorney client privilege, but that exception is narrowly defined to receive legal advice or to discuss pending or possible litigation.

There is no exception to debate or create public policy in executive session.

A conditional use permit is public policy. Establishing conditions on the use of land is public policy. Creating conditions for a permit is public policy.

Public policy is not a commodity to be bought or sold. I can’t come in here and offer you $10,000 if you will give me a conditional use permit to build a barn out of code and then have you go to executive session and send your attorney to me to negotiate how to write that agreement to get the $10,000 and you discuss those terms in executive session.

The Kansas Open Meetings Act does not grant you authority through the attorney client privilege exception to meet in private to negotiate with a developer.

Using the consultation with an attorney is not a blanket legal statement to be able to discuss public policy as long as an attorney is present. Having an attorney serve as a conduit between the commission and a third party developer is not privileged legal advice protected by the attorney client privilege. It is considered ana ttempt at subterfuge between the county and the third party, something not allowed by the Kansas Open Meetings Act.

Commissioner Jairo Vazquez has stated on social media that keeping the discussions private provides the county the ability to better negotiate.

You can’t negotiate public policy in private.

Reaching a setback of 1,900 feet from a wind turbine, for example, is not a determination that can be reached is executive session, and your 78-page proposal is full of policy decisions that were discussed and deliberated in nonpublic conversations claiming attorney client privilege when no privilege exists, and using an attorney as a conduit with a third party and discussing those terms in executive session clearly violates the Kansas Open Meetings Act Attorney Client privilege exception. Having an attorney shuttle terms on a conditional use permit must be done in public under KOMA.

The Kansas Supreme Court has deemed that the role of the county commission on conditional use permits is not just legislative but is also quasi-judicial. That means your decision on a conditional use permit must be based on evidence presented in public rather than pre-arranged privately negotiated agreements. Releasing a fully drafted resolution before public deliberation exposes the permit to legal challenges on the grounds that the commission predetermined the outcome without due process.

That is exactly what happened here. You issued a draft copy that was created without the public witnessing the process, what was discussed or how you reached conclusions on how these decisions were reached.

A district judge, county attorney or the Kansas Attorney General can invalidate any binding action if a commission discussed public policy in executive session, which you have, used an attorney to be a conduit between the commission and a third party and discussed those findings in executive session, which you have, or if you have released a draft copy prior to public deliberation on creating the draft, which you have. Commissioner Mettlen mentioned before the release to just wait until we can all see what was created in executive session.

It is required by law to be done in public. Public policy is not for sale where favorable policies can be purchased from the commission in backdoor discussions.

Not only will the action be voided, but commissioners can face a $500 fine per violation. My math has that conservatively at no less than $10,000 each.

The Kansas Attorney General’s office has been notified, and any binding action under the terms you have presented publicly as a draft copy with policies never discussed in open session will surely be overturned and fines imposed.

Or, you can scrap the illegally produced draft, start the process in public, and not put public policy up for sale. Rather, establish rules and regulations in public discussions with whatever fees may be required to obtain such agreement. Let the public see how policy determinations are made.

I am a lifelong Seward County citizen. I love my home and have dedicated my life to making this the best place it can be. I know each of you care about your home, too. I know you want to do the right thing. You were told negotiating public policy in private was ok. It’s not.

I urge you to discuss this with the Kansas Association of Counties, the Kansas Attorney General’s office and have your own counsel research this before taking any consequential action.

Don’t take a vote under these inappropriate circumstances. It will be voided. Let’s get this right.