LETTER TO THE EDITOR, Ryan Martin, Seward County
Recently, at the Nov. 16 Seward County Commission meeting, it was stated that one of the questions I posed during citizens' comments regarding the Thresher wind development had offended a commissioner. Over the course of the following week, I have pondered that statement quite a bit. It made me think that perhaps it is time to step back and look at this entire process from the beginning.
Let's look at this from a neutral position, neither for nor against wind development. Let's take a completely unbiased look at what has happened.
Over the course of nearly a year, the Seward County Commission negotiated and developed a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for the Thresher wind development. Much of this process took place behind closed doors, with little public discussion, virtually no public insight, and no meaningful opportunity for citizens to participate in developing the regulations. Regulations concerning setbacks, lighting, turbine height, decommissioning, enforcement, and numerous other matters directly affecting county residents.
I have attended nearly every County Commission meeting for over a year, with the exception of one in March. During that time, there has been so little open discussion about the proposed development that one might wonder whether anything was happening at all. The only indication that work was being done was when the commission would break for executive session.
Then, Oct. 28, 2026, out of those closed-door discussions emerged the 78-page Thresher Wind Energy Conditional Use Permit.
A 78-page document that is supposed to contain the regulations protecting Seward County residents and their property, along with several financial promises and contributions from the wind development company intended to sweeten the deal.
Now, remember, we are looking at this from a neutral position. So let's dissect what happened next.
The CUP was released to the public on Oct. 28, and citizens were given until Nov. 12 to review it and voice concerns or recommend changes. These did not have to be changes supporting or opposing wind development. They could simply have been recommendations for stronger setbacks, better lighting requirements, more effective decommissioning provisions, or other protections for neighboring properties.
On Nov. 16, two important items appeared on the commission's agenda.
Item 11: Discussion of bringing the wind development to a public vote.
I thought this was a pretty good idea. In fact, I had brought up the possibility of a public vote during four or five previous commission meetings. I repeatedly encouraged commissioners to listen to the will of the people. I even reminded two commissioners seeking reelection that allowing citizens to have a voice through a public vote would be a good way to demonstrate that they were listening to their constituents.
One would have thought I might have received a little appreciation for trying to help them out. Unfortunately, they apparently saw things differently, and both subsequently lost their reelection by a 68 percent majority.
Item 12: Deliberations on the Conditional Use Permit.
This is where things become particularly disappointing for every Seward County resident.
After nearly a year of negotiations behind close doors a 78-page document, and numerous public concerns, what actually changed?
Nothing.
There were no meaningful amendments to increase setbacks and provide more distance between neighboring properties and turbines. No meaningful improvements were made to clarify how the regulations would be enforced. Nothing substantial was added to strengthen the decommissioning requirements.
And perhaps most disappointing of all, nothing was done to adequately secure the financial contributions promised to Seward County.
The proposed payment arrangement has more holes in it than a kitchen strainer.
Concerns were raised that the proposed Thresher payments and reimbursements would be subject to state taxation. Senate Bill 534 was specifically brought up as a potential threat to the anticipated payments. The concern presented was that Seward County could ultimately receive little or no money from these contributions beginning in 2029.
When this issue was brought to the attention of the Thresher representatives, which tried to side skirt the issue.Their response was that they were lobbying against the bill. This was obviously was not the confidence Seward county residence were looking for or deserve.
Think about that for a moment. Shouldn't the county have secured a financial agreement that protects its interests regardless of what happens with future legislation?
Then there is the payment to residents living within one mile of a turbine.
The current CUP provides for an annual payment of $500.
That's right, I didn't forget a zero. Five hundred dollars a year.
Did the commission attempt to negotiate a higher amount? Did they attempt to improve this provision for the residents who will be living closest to these industrial structures? I saw no indication that they did.
Congratulations, Seward County residents. If you live within one mile of a turbine and qualify under the agreement, you could receive $500 annually after completing the required W-9 paperwork. After applicable taxes, that could leave you with considerably less.
During citizens' comments, Dr. Carolyn Huddleston explained the concerns surrounding the taxation of the proposed county contributions between 2029 and 2039 and how state taxation could substantially reduce the amount ultimately received by Seward County.
Earl Watt also provided a detailed explanation of his concerns regarding the commission's use of more than 70 executive sessions during the negotiations and development of the CUP. He raised questions about potential violations of state statute and discussed the possible financial penalties commissioners could face if violations were established.
These were serious concerns. One would think they would warrant additional consideration before proceeding with a vote that could expose the county to further legal complications.
I also participated in citizens' comments, as I have throughout the past year.
I politely asked all five commissioners, the county administrator, and the planning and zoning administrator whether any of them had accepted a kickback or received any personal benefit in connection with this development.
I did not accuse anyone of anything. I asked a question.
Considering the financial concerns that had just been presented, the potential legal issues surrounding the negotiation process, and the possibility of significant financial consequences for the county, I believe it was a fair question to ask.
Apparently, Commissioner Helm found it offensive.
Commissioner Helm, I simply asked a question. Whether you choose to be offended is your decision. But citizens should be able to ask difficult questions of their elected officials without being made to feel that they have done something wrong.
I was also troubled by the appearance of the meeting itself. The front two rows were reserved for the Thresher legal analysis team, while Seward County citizens were left sitting toward the back. Perhaps there was an explanation for the seating arrangement, but after a year of citizens feeling pushed to the back of this process, it certainly did not send a reassuring message.
What really bothers me is that after all these concerns were brought forward, the commission proceeded as though nothing had been said.
The Conditional Use Permit was developed through a process that, in my opinion, gave the public virtually no meaningful opportunity to participate. It was presented to the public on October , and from November 2 - November 12 comments were accepted and on November 16 it was approved without meaningful amendments addressing the concerns raised.
It is difficult to look at that sequence of events and believe the public's input had any real influence on the final decision.
Four commissioners voted to approve the CUP: Vasquez, Mettlen, Helms, and Louderback. Commissioner Stanton voted against it.
Commissioner Louderback presented a lengthy, prepared motion to approve the permit, which Commissioner Vasquez seconded. With only three meetings remaining in their terms, two commissioners who had recently lost their reelection bids participated in moving this agreement across the finish line.
The decision did not surprise me. In my opinion, several commissioners had made up their minds months ago. The concerns, questions, and comments brought forward by citizens appeared to have little influence on the outcome.
Let's also remember what was missing throughout this entire process.
During a year of commission meetings, I do not recall one meaningful open discussion addressing the health concerns raised by residents, the setbacks, lighting, or the potential effects on neighboring properties.
There was no meaningful public discussion about Michael Amarin and his special-needs daughter, whose family has expressed concerns about the potential effects of living near the development.
There were citizens who repeatedly came before the commission, expressed their concerns, and asked questions. Yet the public never saw those concerns translated into meaningful improvements to the CUP.
The open-session discussions I recall included a presentation by Brice with Invenergy explaining the financial benefits the wind development could bring to Seward County, along with discussions by Commissioner Stanton about the possibility of a public vote.
During June and July, citizens also made comments regarding the proposed development, before the CUP was even completed.
Apparently, those comments did not carry much weight either.
Now, let me make something perfectly clear.
This is not simply about being for or against wind development. Someone can support wind energy and still expect stronger setbacks, better decommissioning requirements, enforceable regulations, secure financial agreements, and transparency from their elected officials.
The purpose of a Conditional Use Permit should be to establish conditions that protect the county and its residents. It should not simply be a document that allows a corporation to move forward with its development.
If the original CUP was adequate, why were the concerns raised by citizens not openly addressed? If the financial contributions were secure, why were there unanswered questions about potential taxation? If the regulations were sufficient, why was there no effort to strengthen them?
These are reasonable questions, and Seward County residents deserve reasonable answers.
The commission had an opportunity to take the concerns of its citizens seriously, strengthen the agreement, and make certain that the interests of Seward County were protected. Instead, four commissioners voted to approve the document without meaningful changes.
In the end, who really benefited from this decision?
Invenergy received the approval it wanted. But what did Seward County residents receive in return? Did neighboring property owners receive stronger protections? Did the county receive a financially secure agreement? Were citizens given meaningful consideration?
I believe those questions speak for themselves.
I have taken a position against wind turbines in Seward County, and I have never attempted to hide that. But even if I supported wind development, I would still expect better from my elected officials.
Our County Commission was elected to represent the people of Seward County. That responsibility should never take a back seat to the interests of a multibillion-dollar corporation.
This was never just about wind turbines. It was about transparency, accountability, and protecting the people and property of Seward County. And in my opinion, the people of this county deserved a whole lot better.

